THEA 142: Development of Dramatic Art I

A discussion of the origins and transformations of primarily Western theatre from its origins to the late 18th century, through texts, artists, and theorists.

Wednesday, February 21, 2007

Meditation 4

The characterization of people in the different plays is varied due to the variety of styles employed by different authors. Aeschylus uses Pylades more dramatically than most; he is the one to convince Orestes to kill his mother by putting it simply, the gods commanded it. In Euripides the one to convince Orestes to kill his mother is Electra. In Sophocles he doesn’t really have to be convinced, also his mother is the first to be killed. Euripides version makes the characters seem much more human, more fleshed out through his use of dialogue. Also Orestes inner and outer conflict with murdering his mother, makes him seem less like a epic hero but rather like the average man stuck in a Catch 22. If he doesn’t kill her he is wrong by the gods, if he does kill her he is wrong by man. Also Electra seems much more vengeful in Euripides version than others, on page 120 of the play, she kills ever single argument of Orestes just to get back at her mother who subjugated her. She is not even really in Aeschylus’s version of the play. Whereas Pylades in Euripides version is simply a plot device for Electra to get married to which I think is a cop out. I feel Aeschylus was more of epic storyteller in his version of events, making it so even though Orestes had a second thought he really never hesitates. Also it is in that version that you really get to see the violence. In Euripides version it seems to happen off screen.

3 Comments:

At 11:50 AM, Blogger Kyle said...

I like the point about the "catch 22". No matter what Orestes does he cannot win. Someone will be made at him. What a terrible situation to be in. Maybe he should get someone else to kill her, the God's and people would be happier. Then again that could just cause more drama and that doesn't happene so i guess we will never know.

 
At 9:57 AM, Blogger Layne said...

I really like some of your observations, especially some of your comments about how there is a different person convincing Orestes to kill his mother in the different versions. I also agree with your comment regarding Orestes seeming more human as a result of his self-conflict. It is true that seeing Orestes struggling with the decision to kill Clytemnestra makes him see less like an invincible hero and more like an average human.

 
At 6:14 PM, Blogger markfoster5 said...

The catch 22 thing reminds me of the movie The Green Mile. Tom Hanks has to kill Jon Coffee because it is his job and the law, but at the same time he is a gift from god and he should trust in his faith and not kill him.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home